Get instant
small business insurance quotes

Home > General Liability Insurance > News

Judge dismisses copyright lawsuit against NBC


Recently, a Los Angeles District Court Judge dismissed a lawsuit filed by a writer claiming that NBC had stolen his idea when the television network created "My Name Is Earl."

Earl ran on NBC for four seasons beginning in 2005 before being cancelled in 2009. The lawsuit was filed by writer Mark Gable, who claims he developed a similar idea for a show in 1995 and circulated his script to the major TV stations.

Gable's show, Karma, allegedly features similar plot points to Earl's pilot episode, in which the main character attempts to correct previous wrongdoings after winning the lottery. Furthermore, Gable contests he had shown his script to the same agency that now represents Earl's co-producer Brad Copeland.

Despite Gable's claims, the presiding judge dismissed the case, stating the two shows were not "substantially similar," the Hollywood Reporter states.

The case highlights the importance of undertaking proper practices, however, as copyright lawsuits can become expensive, especially if a business is found guilty. Furthermore, having business insurance in place for unforeseen legal fees can also help companies in similar cases. 

WHY Business Insurance Now?

Learn why thousands of small businesses trust Business Insurance Now as their insurance agency.

Take 15 minutes to see how we can help you protect your business.

  • FREE, no-obligation quotes.
  • Complete one online application to compare multiple quotes.
  • Fast response—typically less than 24 hours on week days.
  • We are a nationwide insurance agency covering 48 states.
  • We work directly with you to evaluate your insurance options.
  • We only work with the top business insurance carriers in the country.
  • Expert, licensed insurance agents to guide you through the process.